Secession and Doleantie

In September and October 1835, the first people in Aalten separated from the Dutch Reformed Church. The Doleantie followed in 1887.

Old Oosterkerk, Aalten
Oude Oosterkerk

During the nineteenth century, Aalten was affected by two major divisions within Dutch Protestantism: the Secession and, more than fifty years later, the Doleantie. Both led to new congregations in Aalten. The two Reformed traditions did not unite locally until 1909.

Old St Helen's Church, Aalten (1952)
The Old St Helen's Church in Aalten

The Secession

The national Secession began in 1834 in Ulrum, where the Revd Hendrik de Cock and part of his congregation left the Dutch Reformed Church. Dissatisfaction also developed among orthodox Dutch Reformed believers in Aalten. The church council minutes show that in September and October 1835 several inhabitants separated from the denomination.

The first Seceders in Aalten did not yet have a church of their own. They held services in private houses and farms, including Bouhuis, Sondern and Navis. Ministers associated with the Secession, including the Revd Anthony Brummelkamp, travelled to the Achterhoek to lead such gatherings.

This was not without risk. Religious gatherings of more than twenty people required government permission. Seceders and their ministers therefore regularly faced police intervention and fines.

The Secession later also became connected with emigration to North America. In 1846, the first demonstrable group of Aalten Seceders left for the New World. Emigration from Aalten itself had already begun in 1835 with a Catholic group, however, and cannot therefore be explained as a whole by the Secession.

A congregation of their own

A Christian Seceded Congregation was probably instituted in Aalten in July 1843 through the confirmation of office-holders. On 10 October 1843, the congregation submitted a request for recognition to King William II; royal recognition followed on 12 January 1844. In 1845, the congregation acquired its own church building on what is now Oosterkerkstraat, on the site where the later Oosterkerk would stand.

Its first minister was the Revd Derk Breukelaar. He was inducted on 24 September 1846 and remained connected with the Aalten congregation for more than forty years.

The Doleantie

A second division developed in the 1880s within the Dutch Reformed Church. Nationally, the Doleantie opposed the authority of the central church administration and what orthodox Dutch Reformed believers regarded as excessive room for liberal theology.

In Aalten, the orthodox minister the Revd J.H.F. Gangel stood against more liberal forces within the Dutch Reformed congregation. Disputes over church government, catechesis and Christian education made the divisions increasingly visible. Part of this history is described separately in The school struggle in Aalten.

On 15 February 1887, a majority of the Aalten church council decided to withdraw from the Dutch Reformed church authorities. Gangel joined the Doleantie. His colleague, the Revd H.A. van Oostrom Soede, remained within the Dutch Reformed Church.

Conflict over the church

The question of who was entitled to use the Old St Helen's Church led to serious tensions in March 1887. On Sunday 6 March 1887, both parties wanted to hold a service in the building. A disturbance arose around the pulpit, and in the weeks that followed soldiers and police were sent to Aalten to maintain order.

A contemporary description appeared in De Graafschapbode on 19 March 1887. Old Aalten preserves that newspaper article separately as a historical source under the title The Ecclesiastical Situation in Aalten.

The Doleantie congregation was ultimately unable to retain the Dutch Reformed church property. It therefore built a wooden temporary church on Varsseveldsestraatweg, later known as the Plankenkerk, which opened on 1 May 1887. A few years later the Westerkerk was built on Hogestraat.

Church A and Church B

Nationally, the Christian Reformed Church that had emerged from the Secession and the Nederduitsche Gereformeerde Kerken that had emerged from the Doleantie united in 1892 as the Reformed Churches in the Netherlands. In Aalten, a local union could not yet be achieved. The older congregation from the Secession was therefore known as Reformed Church A, while the Doleantie congregation became Reformed Church B.

Only on 1 January 1909 were the two Aalten congregations united to form a single Reformed Church. This ended more than sixty years of separate ecclesiastical traditions that had developed in Aalten from the Secession and the Doleantie.

People and places

Sources

Corrections and additions

Have a correction or addition? Leave a comment below. We incorporate relevant information into the profile and then remove comments that have been processed. Your email address will not be published.

Leave a comment