The school struggle in Aalten

Around 1880, Aalten saw a conflict over Christian education, school governance and church influence. Rev. Gangel played an important role in the dispute.

In the nineteenth century, education was closely bound up with church relations. In Aalten too, different Protestant groups wanted Christian education for their children, but disagreed about who should have a say in how it was organised. After the Rev. J.H.F. Gangel came to Aalten in 1879, that difference of opinion became increasingly pronounced. On 1 March 1884 the local school struggle had a tangible outcome: a separate Dutch Reformed School with the Bible opened on Hogestraat, later known as the Wilhelmina School.

A Christian school

The Rev. Derk Breukelaar had proposed founding a Christian school in Aalten as early as 1853. It took many years before the plan became reality. A school association was founded in 1868, and on 1 December 1869 the School with the Bible opened on Bredevoortsestraat.

The school originated among the Seceders, but its governing body was deliberately not organised as a church board. This meant that children from Dutch Reformed families could also attend, and many did. A supplementary fund, supported in part by church collections, helped families who could not afford the school fees.

Gangel and the Dutch Reformed parents

When the Rev. J.H.F. Gangel came to Aalten in 1879 as an orthodox Dutch Reformed minister, he too strongly supported Christian education. He wanted the Dutch Reformed congregation to contribute towards the school fees of Reformed children, but in return he also wanted Dutch Reformed representation on the school board.

The existing board refused to allow that influence. Its members feared that this would change the school's own character. Dutch Reformed supporters were also denied a vote in board elections. The disagreement developed into a conflict between Gangel and, among others, Breukelaar, who chaired the school board.

Gangel eventually took the matter to the cantonal court, but did not prevail. A separate Christian primary school was then founded on Hogestraat by the Dutch Reformed group. On 1 March 1884 the new Dutch Reformed school for Christian primary education opened there. De Nederlander reported that day that the opening would take place at two o'clock in the afternoon under the direction of the Rev. J.H.F. Gangel. Headmaster Siebel left the existing School with the Bible and moved to the new Dutch Reformed school. The change in staff can also be traced in the sources. De Standaard reported on 19 January 1884 that J. Hemmes of Leiden had been appointed headmaster of the School with the Bible in Aalten. In the 1880–1890 population register, Johannes Hemmes (born in Sint Annaparochie on 23 May 1859), a teacher, subsequently appears as Siebel's successor at the same address: Aalten 310. This confirms that Hemmes continued the existing school, while Siebel moved to the new Dutch Reformed school.

School and Gospel

A lecture on Christian education also caused disagreement within the Dutch Reformed congregation. Gangel wanted a representative of the School en Evangelie (School and Gospel) Union to speak in the Oude Helenakerk. The churchwardens refused permission. More than sixty members of the congregation, including Gangel's liberal colleague the Rev. C.F.S. Pape, supported that decision. The Christian Reformed congregation then made its own church building available for the lecture.

More than a school dispute

The school struggle was therefore not about whether Christian education should exist. Both the Seceders and the orthodox Dutch Reformed considered it important. The conflict centred mainly on governance, influence and the school's denominational direction.

The school dispute thus showed how strained church relations in Aalten had become during the 1880s. A few years later, in 1887, part of the Dutch Reformed congregation under Gangel joined the Doleantie. That broader development is described in Secession and Doleantie in Aalten.

People and places

Sources

  1. GereformeerdeKerken.info – De Gereformeerde Kerk te Aalten (1)
  2. GereformeerdeKerken.info – De Gereformeerde Kerk te Aalten (2)
  3. De Nederlander, 1 maart 1884. Bericht dat de school voor christelijk lager onderwijs van de Nederduits Hervormde Gemeente te Aalten die middag om 2 uur zou worden geopend onder leiding van ds. J.H.F. Gangel.
  4. De Standaard, 19 januari 1884: benoeming van J. Hemmes te Leiden tot hoofdonderwijzer der School met den Bijbel te Aalten.
  5. Bevolkingsregister 1880-1890

Corrections and additions

Have a correction or addition? Leave a comment below. We incorporate relevant information into the profile and then remove comments that have been processed. Your email address will not be published.

Leave a comment